Guerlain is always the brand that I look forward to the most each year when the holiday collections start rolling out, and the last 2 years’ Liu and Crazy Paris collections contained some of my personal favorites from Guerlain ever. With such a strong track record, my expectations were so high that I fell short when I saw the early images of the collection. So much so that I could not even find the motivation to drag myself to a counter to check them out in person. Big mistake, huge!
This year’s Un Soir a L’Opera (or A Night at the Opera for us Anglophiles) brings us back to the grandiosity of the theater, where men dress in tuxedos with bow ties, and the ladies are decked out in gold and glimmering jewels. It is sadly a bygone era, I can never find someone to accompany me to the opera, and my husband could not even tie his own bow tie on our wedding day. So I loved the fact that Guerlain has chosen to celebrate and bring back to our collective consciousness the beauty of that golden age, when people dress up to go out, and opera is regarded as a form of high art.
As always, makeup collections revolve around the eyes, and for Guerlain’s A Night at the Opera collection, this takes the form of the Petrouchka Palette for Eyes & Cheek. I was disappointed that Guerlain chose to name such a key piece of A Night at the Opera after a ballet, but I suppose both theatric art forms are lost today. What is (hopefully) not lost, is the beauty of the sleek golden compact that is Petrouchka. It is the same shape and size as Guerlain’s Parure Gold Powder Foundation and Madame Rougit blush. It is 2-tiered, with 5 eyeshadow shades on the top layer, and 4 blusher and highlighters on the bottom. This is also the only multi-product holiday palette this season that does not feature a cream lip/eye product! Petrouchka Palette also comes with a red elastic bow wrapped around it, which is the first time they have accessorized their palettes, and instructions on the box indicate the bow may be used as a hair tie or wrist band.
Whenever I look at a new collection, I somehow always gravitate towards the eyeshadows first. And these eyeshadows from Guerlain Petrouchka Palette were the reasons why I stayed away from the collection for as long as I did. To be completely honest, they were very unexciting, boring even if you consider the similarities with both the Crazy Paris and Liu palettes. Sara at ColorMeLoud has done a very good job with the comparison swatches so I shall not replicate her work. Even if you do not already own either Crazy Paris or Liu, chances are you already have dupes of these shades in your collection.
From top to bottom, the eyeshadow shades are:
All the shades are soft and creamy to the touch, are well pigmented and applies well. The only exception to this is the pale champagne which seemed to apply slightly patchy on my dry lids. The shades stay on my lids well, but when applied to my lower lash line, I did experience some fallout . They blend like a dream, but being as soft as they are, the eyeshadows did start to fall into my eye crease after the 6th hour, and I also noticed some fading by the end of a long day. Before I scare you off completely, I must state that I am unusually harsh here because I expect absolute perfection from Guerlain.
What IS exciting about the Petrouchka Palette is actually the blusher and highlighter tray hidden in the lower tier.
Until recently, I have only owned 1 Guerlain blush (Madame Rougit from Fall 2013) and whilst it is incredibly pretty, it felt hard to the touch and needed more than the lightest feather touch to show up on my skin. Imagine my excitement when I swatched the Petrouchka blushes and found them soft and creamy to the touch, and very pigmented! So pigmented I over did it yesterday, and spent all day waiting for my red cheeks to fade (which they never did!).
Having experienced much angst trying to lay my hands on the Tom Ford Contouring Cheek Color Duos not too long ago, I was really excited to see 2 pairs of blusher and highlighter in one compact! Swatched from top to bottom:
The way to wear these is to apply the blush shades in the bigger pans along the top of your cheek bones, then dab the smaller highlight shades on the apples of your cheeks for a bit of pop. You can of course use the smaller shades as blushes too, and the medium peach-brown is lovely but you may find the light pink too sheer.
There has also been a lot of complains about how small the sizes of the pans are, and how impossible it is to pick them up with a proper cheek brush. May I suggest using a flatter cheek brush with rounded edge like the Hakuhodo B5519 and just sweep not swirl. And for the smaller pans, I use a highlighter brush like my Hakuhodo S116. These are really pretty blushes, and of a quality that has yet to be seen from Guerlain so far, and makes the entire Petrouchka Palette worth the money even if you completely disregard the eyeshadows!
There are plenty more to Guerlain’s A Night at the Opera Collection, and you can read more about them HERE!
I’m glad that you’re loving this collection! I was pretty excited waiting for Guerlain’s holiday collection, but when I saw the first promo pictures, I felt a little disappointed, just like you. There was nothing that really caught my attention.
Maybe I need to see the products in person? Since you’re loving them, I feel like I need to give them a chance 😉
And I loved your eye look! (I’m a sucker for a golden eyeshadow, lol)
I’m so glad to hear you and I have the same experiences! I think if you’ve been following Guerlain for awhile now, the eyeshadows will look very repetitive. But the blushers are excellent! Thank you for the sweetness, golden eyeshadow is always flattering! 😉
Love the complete look!! Read mostly mediocre reviews about the blushers beforehand so I was pleasantly surprised at how lovely they were. Personally found this year’s eyeshadows easier to apply than Crazy Paris, so it cemented my decision to get the palette.
Mediocre reviews about these blushers, really? I guess the main gripes were with the sizes… but really, these are top notch quality compared to the “standard” Guerlain blushes. And one of the best I have swatched lately. Yes, the eyeshadows are softer as well, and given the monochromatic hues, i guess they’re easier to blend. I just wished there was 1 non-gold/bronze color in there… #neversatisfied
Literally so on the fence about this-you make it looks so beautiful
Stacey | Expat Make-Up Addict xx
Thanks Stacey… :* This one needs to be swatched!
This one looks so gorgeous on you Linda, the last photo tells it all.
I also love the cheek tier more than the eye one, thanks so much for the link love too :-*
Most welcome Sara! Thank you always for the kind words! :**
Oh! The colors on your cheeks are so beautiful! I do love the looks of Guerlain’s holiday palettes, and this year’s even more so, since it doesn’t have a lip product also in the compact (so messy). You look really really beautiful.
Hi Belly, yes it is always annoying to find cream lip shades in an eyeshadow palette… I just wished this wasn’t so monochromatic? Thank you so much for your sweet compliments! :*
This is a nice palette for sure, and Guerlain always makes beautiful Holiday collections. I went crazy over Liu but Crazy Paris was kinda meh to me. This one isn’t too bad, but it doesn’t make my heart pitter patter like the Liu palette.
Hi Lily, you’re so right about the Liu palette! That was my 1st Guerlain love, and I went out to the mall with a newborn baby in tow just to buy that one! Imagine me all blurry eyed, extremely lacking in sleep, all crazy-haired and harressed… LOL! Crazy Paris was interesting because of that pink, a little out of character for Guerlain perhaps, but fun. And this one is Guerlain all grown up. I just wished it wasn’t the same gold-copper-bronze shades all over again!
This is probably my favorite collection this season! A typical holiday collection can be done well, and Guerlain has proven that. Love how the palette looks on you! I’m going to photograph mine in a sec. Can’t wait!
Hi Sunny! I wished I could say this is my fav Holiday collection this year… i really want to!! But Guerlain seems to have messed up the distribution here in Singapore, the palette came out late Oct alone.. then the meteorites popped out 2 weeks later, we’re still waiting for the spray! And apparently the 2 KissKiss lippies won’t be coming here at all!! :(( Very hard to get hyped up this way.
I love this palette so much. I agree with the sizes of the blushers though. They would have done just as well with one blusher and one highlighter really. The shades of eyeshadows are beautiful, shame they don’t last. I think if i traveled a lot, i would purchase this palette; however, I don’t and i have similar colours in other eyeshadows. I may weaken though and buy it.
Hi Mandy, thanks for your comment! Lovely to hear from you again! If you don’t have dupes of the eyeshadows….. what are you waiting for?!?!?? LOL!!